With Feinstein on Her Way Out, Can a Progressive Win Her Senate Seat?

After three a long time within the Senate, Dianne Feinstein has introduced that she will not seek re-election in 2024, giving Californians a worthwhile alternative to elect a progressive to the higher chamber. On this strong blue state, three distinguished Democrats within the Home — Adam Schiff, Katie Porter and Barbara Lee — are keen to interchange her.

Schiff has already received a fervent endorsement from former Home Speaker Nancy Pelosi, and far of the get together’s company institution is lining up behind him. A frequent visitor on networks like CNN and MSNBC, the Los Angeles-area consultant has ably served the military-industrial advanced since coming into Congress in 2001, together with along with his 2002 vote to authorize the invasion of Iraq.

Schiff’s nationwide media presence has spiked upward as a member of the Home Intelligence Committee and the January 6 Choose Committee. He has cultivated a status as a defender of freedom in opposition to the evils of the Kremlin and MAGA Republicans. However Schiff isn’t any pal of civil liberties — he has worked to prevent constitutional rights from taking priority over the U.S. authorities’s mass surveillance applications.

Company energy can be properly represented within the Senate by Schiff. Amar Shergill, chair of the California Democratic Social gathering’s giant Progressive Caucus, informed Truthout that Schiff, like Porter and Lee, has pledged to not take company PAC cash within the upcoming marketing campaign — an indication of progressive organizing energy in California” — however, he added, “Schiff most actually shouldn’t be progressive.”

Two months in the past, Schiff voted in opposition to the bloated price range within the Nationwide Protection Authorization Act, saying that it elevated navy spending “past what was requested by the commander-in-chief.” However Shergill noticed that “Schiff voted for navy price range will increase for 20 years till voting in opposition to in December 2022 in a reasonably clear pivot to the Senate marketing campaign.”

Regardless of the left-leaning inclinations of most voters within the state, many activists worry that Consultant Schiff is well-positioned to turn into Senator Schiff when 2025 begins. Shergill expressed hope that just one main progressive candidate will stay within the race, in order that votes from the left received’t be break up. The fragmenting effects of a number of progressive candidates in New York Metropolis’s mayoral election in 2021, leading to victory for regressive candidate Eric Adams, quantity to a cautionary story.

“We are going to consider the campaigns over the following few months,” Shergill stated, including that “if the progressive candidates really consider within the ethos of group over self, all however one will step apart earlier than the first to make sure that a progressive reaches the final election poll.” Underneath California’s top-two system, given GOP weak spot within the state, two Democrats may find yourself dealing with off within the November common election subsequent yr.

In contrast to Adam Schiff and Barbara Lee, who’ve represented strong Democratic districts for many years, Katie Porter has received hard-fought races in opposition to Republicans in Orange County and is now in her fifth yr in Congress. She has impressed many progressives along with her vigorously anti-corporate “whiteboard” shows. Porter hits onerous on financial injustice — however has not engaged a lot on international coverage issues.

Lee offers a distinction with each of her main declared opponents — particularly Schiff — on some points of militarism. In Congress since 1998, she has lengthy loved an exalted status amongst progressives, most notably for her brave lone vote in opposition to the blank-check authorization for countless battle that Congress authorised shortly after 9/11. Her legislative battles on behalf of low-income individuals and her persistent advocacy for reducing Pentagon budgets have additionally been notable.

But, as years have passed by, Barbara Lee’s independence from the Democratic Social gathering energy construction has diminished. She can be an enormous enchancment over the low bar of Dianne Feinstein, significantly better than Schiff on home and particularly international coverage, and extra probably than Porter to generally be a thorn within the ironside of the Pentagon. However, based mostly on Lee’s political habits lately, those that view her as a constant foe of the warfare state are mistaken. Particularly with a Democrat within the Oval Workplace, she has pulled her political punches moderately than immediately confront the militarism of the commander in chief.

Longtime antiwar activist Bert Knorr, who lives in Berkeley, has turn into outspoken as a constituent of Barbara Lee. Whereas noting that she “has a status of being one of many strongest advocates for peace in Congress,” Knorr stated that he has been “deeply dissatisfied by her repeated votes for a complete of over $110 billion for the battle in Ukraine. … In 2022 she voted in lockstep with each Democrat in Congress behind President Biden’s battle coverage with out voicing questions or issues about escalation and the necessity for a peaceable decision to the battle.”

Knorr added, “At a time when the world is at rising threat of nuclear battle, Lee’s voice for peace is obviously absent. She has refused to fulfill with peace activists or constituents to debate her place or take into account different views.”

Through the Trump presidency, Lee voiced outrage that the chief of the U.S. authorities would meet at a summit along with his Russian counterpart. In 2019, Lee endorsed then-Senator Kamala Harris for president and went on to function her California marketing campaign co-chair.

The state get together may now play an essential position in what guarantees to be a free-for-all contest to interchange Feinstein. Sadly, over the last a number of years, the California Democratic Social gathering (CDP) has devolved into one thing near a de facto dictatorship below its corporate-oriented chair, Rusty Hicks. Candidates can be vying for the CDP’s endorsement earlier than the first election subsequent yr — an element that would help Schiff, given the consolidated top-down company leverage over the state get together’s operations.

As a member of the CDP’s central committee for 10 years, I’ve seen dynamics steadily worsen contained in the political sausage manufacturing facility. Institution Democrats in California’s legislature have an outsized grip on a lot of the state get together, whereas grassroots activists wrestle to push again. As CDP chair, Hicks appears to be channeling the likes of Chicago’s Mayor Richard J. Daley (the infamous Democratic “boss”), doing all he can to eviscerate practical democracy contained in the get together whereas working to undermine the impacts of its progressive base.

One of many hallmarks of the California Democratic Social gathering is that just about everybody in its management claims to be “progressive.” It’s a declare that Adam Schiff is certain to make as he targets progressive voters. Whereas Schiff’s longstanding assist for company energy and militarism may undermine his quest to turn into California’s subsequent senator, his possibilities of successful can be bolstered if a couple of robust progressive candidate stays within the race in opposition to him.

A fast message earlier than you retain studying

We’re proud to publish actual information three hundred and sixty five days of the yr, utterly freed from cost to our readers. However producing high-quality, unbiased work shouldn’t be cost-free – we rely closely in your assist.

When you discovered the piece above helpful, informative, or inspiring, please take into account supporting Truthout with a tax-deductible donation. A present of any dimension makes a distinction and helps maintain this distinctive platform alive.