Immigrant Women Workers Are Fighting to Close Disney’s Gender Pay Gap

Disney World employees in Central Florida are battling with administration for a brand new and improved union contract. Within the course of, they’re additionally attempting to right a gaping historic injustice.

Employees with the Worldwide Alliance of Theatrical Stage Staff (IATSE) Native 631 say a serious pay hole exists at Disney World that leaves employees in historically feminized jobs, reminiscent of costume-making, incomes considerably lower than employees in historically masculinized jobs with comparable expertise ranges, reminiscent of stagehand labor.

The union — which represents the expert crafts individuals who work behind the scenes in Disney World leisure, from costume employees to cosmetologists to stage technicians — is demanding in bargaining that Disney shut this gender pay hole by elevating wages in historically feminized jobs to carry them in alignment with comparatively expert however historically male-dominated jobs.

The union says that Disney’s personal inside data attest to a major gendered pay disparity between job classifications. In line with the union, the roles that earn much less are additionally disproportionately held by older immigrant ladies from Vietnam, Latin America and the Caribbean.

“What we’re speaking about is a mass undercompensation of talent and talent as a result of the classification has been traditionally feminine,” stated Paul Cox, president of IATSE Native 631. “That is work that ought to be appropriately compensated.”

The Labor Behind the Magic

Behind the “magic” of the Snow Whites and Buzz Lightyears, behind the cruises and the live shows, is the labor that makes Disney World leisure attainable.

IATSE Native 631 shared information with Truthout that reveals notable pay disparities throughout Disney World’s behind-the-scenes leisure job classifications.

For instance, 12 classifications with a mixed a number of hundred employees throughout building stitching (making costumes), operations stitching (altering and repairing costumes), costuming assistants (number of roles aiding costume-making) and costume employees (costume dressers, operations, logistics and upkeep) all have low charges beginning between $15 and $15.40 per hour and excessive charges from $19.25 to $20.55 per hour.

These roles are historically seen as “ladies’s jobs” and are at the moment made up overwhelmingly of girls employees: 87 p.c of building stitching employees, 93 p.c of operations stitching employees, 92 p.c of costuming assistants and 78 p.c of costume employees establish as ladies.

In distinction, the 5 classifications throughout technician positions (stagehands) have low charges beginning between $16.65 and $24.25 per hour and excessive charges that attain $21.91 to $31.07 per hour. Of the a number of hundred technician positions, 80 p.c are males.

Cox is a stage 1 technician, a crew chief among the many stagehands who do backstage labor reminiscent of lighting, sound and pyrotechnics. He says that these totally different job classifications contain comparable talent ranges, and that the one clarification behind the pay disparity is the corporate’s devaluing of jobs historically held by ladies.

Even among the feminized jobs that pay extra — reminiscent of cosmetology and milliners, each 86 p.c ladies — have a low wage of $16.90 and a excessive wage of $23.36, which compares much less to the upper paid male-typed jobs. Some promotions inside feminized job classifications, reminiscent of with costume specialist, don’t even include raises, says Cox.

Hoa Dang is a stitching specialist who immigrated from Vietnam in 2007 and began working at Disney World in 2009. She instructed Truthout that she actually likes her job, particularly the “pleasant, sociable working surroundings.”

After almost 13 years, she at the moment makes $18.44 per hour, which is simply above the bottom beginning price for a stage 3 technician and a few greenback beneath the bottom beginning price for a stage 2 technician, each male-dominated classifications. She says she helps the union’s present efforts.

Cox says aligning wage charges to repair the gender pay hole is lengthy overdue.

“I can acknowledge the talent and the dedication that these employees have,” Cox stated. “And I can acknowledge the truth that this employer has massively taken benefit of them.”

“Walt Would Cry”

Cindy Hsu is just 28, however she’s seen loads since she joined Disney World in 2018. She’s labored as a stitcher, a lifeguard, a stitching workroom coordinator and now as a sample maker, the place she enjoys the fun of working with designers and administrators to develop Disney’s reveals and characters.

Hsu loves working at Disney World and making the park’s “magic” come to life for guests.

However the gender pay hole on the firm has been “a longstanding drawback” in her occupation as a result of costuming has been “seen as a ladies’s position,” Hsu instructed Truthout.

“Our complete costume division is simply seen as ‘lesser’ than an leisure rigger or technician,” she stated.

Hsu burdened the profound stage of talent that goes into costuming work. Stitchers have to take a rigorous, three-hour take a look at, and many candidates don’t cross. They make and restore intricate clothes that should be precise replicas of costumes from a half-century in the past. They work with giant and harmful industrial stitching equipment.

“This isn’t your grandma’s dwelling stitching machine,” she stated.

Hsu says the devaluing of costuming labor feels “very archaic now” due to the demanding nature of the work.

“We’re very a lot on par with riggers and the individuals who do present manufacturing,” she stated.

Christine Martell, a building help specialist with an experience in customized embroidery, agrees. At 58 years previous, she’s been with the corporate for 23 years. Martell earns $21.54 per hour, the best price for her job classification — simply barely greater than the $21.25 that’s the lowest price for a stage 1 technician, 80 p.c of whom are males.

Martell, who can also be a union store steward, says that “techs are nice” and that she desires “us going up” and “not them taking place.”

However the sense that her and her coworkers’ expertise are valued much less grates on her.

“I can put staging up,” she stated. “Are you able to make a marriage gown? Can you set a zipper in? Are you able to run a blind hemmer?”

Martell shared descriptions of a number of costuming jobs with Truthout. The job description of a stitching operation specialist 2, for instance, spills into 4 pages and consists of over two dozen expertise that vary from “intensive data of garment building and alteration to be utilized to all kinds of costume clothes” to “willingness to be taught and additional educate ourselves and others in new strategies and strategies to higher enhance effectivity,” in addition to the flexibility to make use of 17 varieties of stitching equipment and fulfill totally different required lessons and trainings.

Round 92 p.c of stage 2 stitching operation specialists are ladies, in response to the information offered by the union. They earn between $15.25 and $19.92 per hour. They’re certainly one of various job classes that make up Disney World’s stitchers, the gender-neutral time period for what have historically been known as seamstresses.

Stitchers are one of many core behind-the-scenes jobs negatively impacted by the wage hole. A disproportionately giant variety of Disney World’s stitchers are immigrants from Vietnam and Latin America. They’re principally ladies, but additionally embrace a smaller variety of males and employees whose gender is undefined. Many cultivated their stitching expertise by years of labor and coaching of their dwelling nations. Many don’t communicate a lot English.

They’re “wildly proficient,” says Hsu, who labored as a stitcher for round two years. “You can provide them something below the solar they usually can replicate it for you.”

Each Hsu and Martell say Disney will get away with paying them much less due to the language boundaries and the difficulties they’ve in advocating for themselves.

“I really feel like to a point, they’re being taken benefit of,” Hsu says.

Hsu says many forged members have to work two jobs to outlive. Some reside of their automobiles, sleeping in grocery retailer parking heaps.

“It’s extremely troublesome to see that taking place,” she stated. “It’s simply an unseen a part of this ‘magic.’”

Hsu says it’s laborious to obtain messages from firm executives that tout excessive earnings whereas “forged members are struggling to get by.” She introduced up a well-known quote by Walt Disney that she as soon as noticed at Disney World: “You may design and create, and construct probably the most fantastic place on the earth. Nevertheless it takes individuals to make the dream a actuality.”

She paused for a second.

“I actually really feel like Walt would cry realizing that his forged members are struggling.”

Patriarchal Values Form Our Financial system

Cox says that the union has offered the pay disparities to Disney at bargaining, “making the purpose that these classifications with these immense quantities of expertise are vastly underpaid, they usually’re majority feminine.”

The corporate’s response, he stated, has been “We don’t pay forged members in a different way as a result of they’re male or feminine.” Truthout reached out to Disney for remark however didn’t obtain a response.

The union says Disney is evading the deeper problem right here: The issue is much less about overt discrimination and extra that the corporate doesn’t place as a lot worth on historically feminized jobs, reminiscent of stitching and costuming, because it does on work involving comparable talent ranges which are historically male-dominated, reminiscent of stage technician work.

Truthout spoke with Pilar Gonalons-Pons, an professional on gender and work on the College of Pennsylvania. “One of many main contributors to the gender wage hole is occupational job segregation,” she stated, “which is mainly the truth that job titles of girls are usually totally different from the job titles of males, even when they’re in the identical trade and even in the identical firm.”

She stated this could result in a complete job class “being devalued partly as a result of it’s gendered and racialized, or it’s disproportionately executed by these ladies who’re presumed to be low-skilled.”

Gonalons-Pons says that lots of the expertise concerned in feminized professions are “presumed to be pure attributes of the ladies that do the roles versus precise expertise which have been realized and perfected over loads of follow in numerous conditions.”

Quite a few research illustrate the persistence of a racialized gender wage hole throughout the U.S. workforce. For instance, a Nationwide Ladies’s Regulation Heart study discovered that ladies as a complete had been paid simply 73 cents for each greenback earned by males throughout 2020. That pay hole is larger for girls of coloration, with Black ladies being paid 64 cents, and Latina and Native American ladies incomes 57 cents for each greenback earned by white, non-Hispanic males. In consequence, ladies employees on common lose out on tons of of hundreds of {dollars} in earnings over their lives as in comparison with males.

“The wage hole is basically the fee to ladies of residing and dealing in an financial system that has patriarchal values and that systematically devalues and underpays jobs which are feminized and expertise which are related to femininity,” says Gonalons-Pons

Combating to Shut the Gender Wage Hole

The present negotiations with Disney World are Cox’s first as IATSE Native 631 president. He says the wage hole is a “historic sin” that has lengthy existed within the reside leisure trade and that it’s “the fault of our union for not taking this up sooner.”

Cox says the union is now “completely dedicated” to doing all the pieces it may “to right this problem.” He says IATSE Native 631 has the agency backing of the opposite 5 union locals that collectively make up the Service Trades Council Union that bargains with Disney World.

Within the union’s present proposals, Cox says most feminized classifications which have been historically paid much less would see a 20 p.c to 26 p.c enhance that will carry them into parity with male-typed classifications. Mixed with the final raises the union is asking for all forged members, tons of of behind-the-scenes employees, principally ladies, might see as a lot as a 30 to 40 p.c pay enhance inside a yr, assuming the union wins its full calls for.

The union estimates that it will value Disney round $5 million to initially shut the wage hole — a small fraction of the $130 million that CEO Bob Iger took in from 2019 and 2022 in response to Disney’s financial filings.

For a corporation that claims to help diversity, equity and inclusion, says Cox, this can be a small value to pay.

The union is working laborious to prove members who traditionally haven’t had sufficient illustration. Dozens of stitchers and different costume employees have attended bargaining rallies.

Hsu says that bigger numbers of Vietnamese forged members are turning out for union negotiations. “I really feel like that’s very telling about how sad they’re with issues,” she stated.

Hsu’s voice creaks with laughter as she describes her “the quantity of pantomiming that occurs in our foolish workroom” as forged members who communicate totally different languages “attempt to talk with each other by footage or hand indicators.”

“It’s so enjoyable seeing them work collectively.”

She hopes that the present bargaining can lastly ship raises in wages that may shut the wage hole at Disney World.

“We’re right here making the visitors their dream holidays and bringing beautiful characters that they’d of their childhood to life,” she says. “I simply want that the corporate would worth that a bit extra.”

A fast message earlier than you retain studying

We’re proud to publish actual information twelve months of the yr, utterly freed from cost to our readers. However producing high-quality, impartial work will not be cost-free – we rely closely in your help.

If you happen to discovered the piece above helpful, informative, or inspiring, please think about supporting Truthout with a tax-deductible donation. A present of any dimension makes a distinction and helps preserve this distinctive platform alive.