What the irresistible rise of Anas Sarwar reveals about the state of Scottish politics

The winds of change are blowing by way of Scottish politics. After over a decade of domination, each at Holyrood and in Scottish seats at Westminster, a sense of unease is creeping into the ranks of the Scottish Nationwide Celebration (SNP). If the Supreme Courtroom’s ruling on a second independence referendum was an anticipated, if tough, setback — then the latest row over a transgender prisoner has proved each surprising and deeply politically fraught. Inner critics argue the battle has scuppered momentum for Scotland’s newest independence push. 

All that is coupled with persistent whispers about Nicola Sturgeon’s personal future. The altering of the SNP guard at Westminster, which noticed Stephen Flynn (34) and Black (28) oust Ian Blackford (61) and Kirsten Oswald (50) as group chief and deputy respectively, could have set ominous cogs in movement. Whereas some SNP supporters could discover it simpler to think about an finish to the world than an finish to Sturgeon, Flynn has already provided some not-so-subtle hints that Nationalism’s SW1 arm will function extra independently in future.  

As David Cameron would possibly say, Sturgeon was the longer term as soon as.

The electoral stakes for the SNP have additionally upped considerably in latest months following the revival of Scottish Labour below chief Anas Sarwar. Buoyed by rising ballot numbers, the 39-year-old needs to show the SNP’s disaster of identification into certainly one of outright survival. 


Firearms licensing is in disaster, BASC tells Parliamentary Committee inquiry


BASC logo

BASC’s scholarship programme open for 2023 functions

The return of an auld tune

It has been a very long time since Scottish Labour felt optimistic. On the 2015 normal election Labour was diminished to only one MP north of the border. The SNP had steamrollered the 56 different seats, laying the foundations for a nonetheless largely unchallenged nationalist ascendency at Westminster. 

Scottish Labour has felt the ache in Holyrood, too. It has not held the primary minister’s put up since 2007, and below the management of Kezia Dugdale and Corbynite Richard Leonard, the get together at occasions plunged as little as 13% in Holyrood election polls. When Leonard resigned as Scottish Labour chief in 2021, simply 10 weeks out from a Holyrood election, polling instructed that the get together was set to complete a dismal fourth.

Upon changing Leonard as get together chief, Sarwar catalysed a quick revival of Scottish Labour’s fortunes. Stemming the tide in Labour’s ailing help, Sarwar noticed his get together to a third-placed end within the 2021 Holyrood elections, choosing up 21.6% of the constituency vote.  

To make sure, Sarwar’s ascent has not been from whole obscurity — somewhat in contrast to his millennial compatriot in Stephen Flynn. He’s the son of the UK’s first Muslim MP, Mohammed Sarwar, and has served variously as an MP at Westminster, a shadow minister below Ed Miliband and even deputy chief of Scottish Labour earlier than assuming put up as chief. However solely now has Sarwar actually established a UK-wide popularity. 

Below Sarwar, Scottish Labour has skilled considerably of a renaissance, siphoning off anti-independence swing voters who’re disillusioned with the Conservative’s efficiency at Westminster and unenthused by the Scottish management supplied by Douglas Ross. 

One latest ballot surveying Westminster voting intention discovered Scottish Labour had elevated their fortunes to 31%, simply forward of the Scottish Conservatives at 15% and encroaching, slowly however certainly, on the SNP juggernaut. 

Foysol Choudhury MSP, Sarwar’s shadow tradition minister in Holyrood, credit “Anas’ daring and revolutionary management” for the comeback. Talking to politics.co.uk he argued that Scottish Labour “would assist to remodel Scotland’s future” and sort out its state of “perpetual disaster” instituted by Sturgeon and the SNP.

“[Under Sarwar, Scottish Labour is] introducing concrete plans which might assist to remodel Scotland’s future and sort out the issues that our constituents up and down the nation are sadly going through, from the NHS disaster to the cost-of-living disaster”, Choudhury added. 

In fact, the get together continues to be someway off the dominant SNP. However Scottish Labour figures contend that Nationalism’s hardening angle in the direction of independence presents a possibility prepared for exploitation. 

The get together is more and more snug on the “nationwide query”, partially because of the work of Gordon Brown’s Constitutional Fee. The publication of Gordon Brown’s report on the UK structure noticed Labour push a “third means” on Scotland and, tellingly, Sarwar was entrance and centre of the launch of the proposals.

Brown’s report supplied for a “legally binding” substitute for the Sewel Conference, the concept MPs ought to solely legislate throughout devolved areas with specific consent from Holyrood; the granting of additional international affairs powers to Holyrood; elevated session on the devolution of powers for Holyrood; and a “solidarity clause” requiring every of the UK’s governments to work collectively. The dedication moreover to a “senate of the nations” higher chamber, first backed by Sarwar final summer season, would show a major constitutional innovation. 

So with the SNP planning to run the subsequent normal election as a “de facto” indyref2, Scottish Labour could really feel able to step outwith financial points and problem Sturgeon on her personal floor.

Remaining challenges

Brown’s devolutionary zeal however, one potential blot in Scottish Labour’s revival below Sarwar could be the socio-political furore surrounding the “gender” query. Again in December, 18 of Labour’s 22 MSPs backed the Gender Recognition Reform Invoice, regardless of the get together expressing their desire for sure rejected amendments. 

The fallout from the invoice’s passage noticed secretary of state for Scotland Alister Jack subject a Part 35 order to dam the laws, leaving SNP MSPs roundly outraged. The authorized struggle with the British authorities now seems to be more likely to derail the laws and the Scottish Labour is not going to emerge unscathed. Keir Starmer’s intervention within the debate, through which he expressed “issues in regards to the provision in Scotland, specifically the age discount to 16”, gave purpose for the outdated jibe that the Scottish get together is merely a UK Labour “department workplace” to return. Sarwar later defended Starmer for not falling into the “Tory lure”.

One other subject could also be that of Brexit. Scotland voted overwhelmingly to stay within the EU within the 2016 referendum, a truth which the SNP has been at pains to take advantage of. Comparatively, UK Labour has embraced the language of Brexit, accepting Britain’s departure from the EU largely uncritically. Despite the fact that Starmer has argued for a step-by-step, issue-by-issue strategy to the UK-EU relationship, the acceptance of Brexit probably leaves Sarwar saddled with a place that’s nonetheless deeply unpopular in Scotland.

It’s points like these that Sarwar might want to overcome if he’s to show Scottish Labour from distant second to outright frontrunner. 

However Sarwar doesn’t cover his ambition. He has argued vociferously that Scotland was Labour’s authentic “crimson wall”, and set his sights on constructing again the stronghold brick-by-brick. It’ll naturally take a while earlier than Labour Labour can reassert itself because the voice of the Scottish folks — a place it as soon as loved unchallenged. However the renewed sense of optimism below Sarwar, with polling numbers lastly pointing in the fitting path, might be able to open up a significant new entrance for Labour come 2024. 

One small however vital manifestation of Scottish Labour’s broader optimism is that parliamentary candidate alternatives in Scotland are attention-grabbing once more. On February 12, the seat of East Lothian will choose a candidate for 2024 and the frontrunner is former cupboard minister Douglas Alexander. The returning Alexander, no less than, thinks that Scottish Labour get together is newly aggressive.

Nonetheless, Sarwar’s rise additionally has significance past his get together’s electoral prospects. For in him and Flynn, Scotland has a brand new era of leaders. In fact, each nonetheless have a lot to show and Sturgeon’s extra excitable critics could be incorrect to recommend that her finish is nigh. However an auld cycle in Scottish politics, whereby political secession is nearly indefinitely generational, is revolving anew. 

The irresistible rise of millennials Flynn and Sarwar will now place Sturgeon’s Scottish supremacy below concerted generational pressure.