‘My-Side-ism’ Media Bias on Other Side of Pond

Conservative media watchdogs who seek to correct the distortions of liberal news outlets are often met with hypocrisy.

“You can’t complain about bias,” they say, “because you’re awfully biased yourself.”

This would be a more impressive argument if one was a mirror image of the media, insisting that the one True Way of Journalism was to sound exactly like a conservative and only issue “news” that favors your side because your side is the staunch defense of “democracy” and “truth.”

Insisting that the media ought to reflect both sides—which actually sounds more like democracy—is despised as a conservative plot.

A recent article in The Guardian shows the socialist news effort of Britain’s Guardian. Former BBC anchor (aka “presenter”) Emily Maitlis complained in a lecture at a television festival in Edinburgh, Scotland, that BBC board member Robbie Gibb was an “agent of the Conservative Party” who was acting “as the arbiter of BBC impartiality.”

The BBC doesn’t want anyone fussing about impartiality. It doesn’t need outside arbitrators. They cook it with a socialist flavour, and the masses should accept their sermons rather than complain about the taxpayer-funded broadcaster.

Gibb was previously the communications director for former Conservative Prime Minister Theresa May. This accusation is legitimate. He was appointed to the BBC Board by Prime Minister Boris Johnson, where he’s now seen as a troublemaker upsetting the Labour Party apple cart.

Exhibit A was Maitlis popping off when she anchored “Newsnight,” attacking Johnson adviser Dominic Cummings for a breach of lockdown protocols during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. She lectured that Cummings has “broken the rules” and “the country can see that, and it’s shocked [that] the government cannot.”

Maitlis was upset that after the prime minister’s office complained, the BBC aired a public apology, the recording was taken down, and “there were paparazzi outside my front door.” She complained that the BBC did this “without any kind of due process”—as if this were a court case.

The Guardian summarized that Maitlis’ lament was that the BBC slipped into a “both-sides-ism” approach to impartiality that gave a platform to individuals that did not deserve airtime. But isn’t airing both sides the definition of being impartial?

Maitlis added that during the Brexit referendum, the BBC would “create a false equivalence” by presenting a pro-Brexit economist with an anti-Brexit economist, which was obnoxious because “the overwhelming majority of economists felt Brexit was a bad idea.”

Conservative complaints about media bias were causing anchors to “censor our own interviews” and to fail to defend themselves as “facts are getting lost” and “constitutional norms trashed.”

Do you feel familiar?

The left thinks it’s the “democratic norm,” that they act as the bold “truth tellers” who explain nightly that the conservatives are basically the Enemies of the People. The media shouldn’t be “complacent, compliant onlookers,” as Maitlis sees it. They should be the frog leaping out of the boiling water “and phoning all its friends to warn them.”

Allowing two sides would be “normalizing the absurd.”

In other words, journalists believe they are society’s enlightened elites, self-appointed to run governments through their televised wisdom. Anyone who gets in the way with their benighted appeals to “both-sides-ism” is getting in the way of their power to shape minds for “the right side of history.”

They believe only in “my-side-ism.”

Then they conclude that anyone who disagrees with this arrogant arrangement hates democracy—and they wonder why they’re unpopular.


The Daily Signal is open to all perspectives. Nothing here should be taken to mean that The Heritage Foundation views are represented.

Are you a fan of this article? To sound off, please email letters@DailySignal.com and we’ll consider publishing your edited remarks in our regular “We Hear You” feature. Include the article’s URL or headline, along with your name and the address of your town or state.