Taking a stand. J.Ok. Rowling‘s controversial transphobic remarks have left each Harry Potter‘s followers and solid members feeling conflicted.
The creator first got here underneath fireplace in June 2020, when she shared a number of posts on Twitter that appeared to slam the trans neighborhood. “If intercourse isn’t actual, there’s no same-sex attraction. If intercourse isn’t actual, the lived actuality of ladies globally is erased,” Rowling wrote on the time, arguing that she had researched the subject for meany years earlier than sharing her opinion. “I do know and love trans individuals, however erasing the idea of intercourse removes the power of many to meaningfully talk about their lives. It isn’t hate to talk the reality.”
Her posts earned quite a lot of backlash from social media customers, lots of whom accused Rowling of being a “TERF,” which stands for trans-exclusionary radical feminist. The author, nevertheless, defended her stance in a prolonged essay in June 2020.
“Accusations of TERFery have been enough to intimidate many individuals, establishments and organisations I as soon as admired, who’re cowering earlier than the ways of the playground,” she claimed on the time. “Talking as a organic girl, lots of people in positions of energy really want to develop a pair (which is probably actually potential, in response to the type of people that argue that clownfish show people aren’t a dimorphic species).”
Because the controversy continued, a number of members of the Harry Potter universe together with Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson and Rupert Grint, appeared to distance themselves from Rowling. “I firmly stand with the trans neighborhood,” Grint mentioned in a press release to Us Weekly in June 2020. “Trans girls are girls. Trans males are males. We should always all be entitled to stay with love and with out judgment.”
Whereas lots of the franchise’s stars opened disagreed with the producer, others have maintained that they nonetheless respect Rowling and her influence on their careers. Jason Isaacs, for his half, opened up about his “difficult” emotions concerning the Informal Emptiness creator in a January 2022 interview with The Telegraph.
“There’s a bunch of stuff about Jo. You already know, I play difficult individuals, I’m eager about difficult individuals,” the actor, who portrayed Lucius Malfoy all through the collection, mentioned on the time. “I don’t wish to get drawn into the trans points, speaking about them, as a result of it’s such a unprecedented minefield. She has her opinions, I’ve mine. They differ in many various areas.”
Regardless of their opposing factors of view, Isaacs needed to acknowledge all the “good” Rowling has performed over time via the Harry Potter collection and her charity work. “One of many issues that individuals ought to find out about her too — not as a counter-argument — is that she has poured an unlimited quantity of her fortune into making the world a significantly better place, for tons of of 1000’s of susceptible youngsters, via her charity Lumos,” he defined, including that his former costars have volunteered with Lumos and “seen on the bottom the work that they do.”
The philanthropist, nevertheless, has continued to double down on her opinions. Rowling reacted to a report by The Sunday Occasions alleging that Scottish police will “report rapes by offenders with male genitalia as being dedicated by a girl if the attacker ‘identifies as a feminine,’” in December 2021. “Warfare is Peace. Freedom is Slavery. Ignorance is Energy. The Penised Particular person Who Raped You Is a Girl,” the screenwriter wrote on Twitter.
Amid all of her controversies, Rowling didn’t participate in HBO’s latest Harry Potter twentieth Anniversary reunion particular however was as a substitute featured in archival footage shot in 2019.
Hold scrolling to see what different Hogwarts alums have mentioned about Rowling over time.