A court docketing error on Tuesday briefly exposed documents in the Mar-a-Lago probe that were supposed to be sealed — and revealed a stark difference between U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon’s description of documents and the actual documents she described.
A court error was briefly exposed sealed Justice Department filingThe following lists of potentially privileged materials seized at Mar-a-Lago were published by Bloomberg’s Zoe Tillman. The Aug. 30 letter to Cannon, a Trump appointee who ordered a special master review of the documents at the former president’s request, detailed the DOJ’s efforts to set aside any potentially privileged material that was unrelated to the investigation.
Cannon in her initial orderA judge blocked the DOJ’s criminal investigation into classified documents. Trump could have been harmed by this order. However, an appeals court overturned that portion of her order. agreed with the DOJ that Cannon “abused” her authority. Legal experts on Wednesday also noted that the letter undercut Cannon’s description of the documents in the matter.
“It is interesting to see the difference between how Judge Cannon described documents and the underlying documents she purportedly described,” tweeted former federal prosecutor Renato Mariotti.
In one case, Cannon expressed concern that the documents included “medical records” that could leak and risk “irreparable injury” to Trump actually appears to be the infamous noteHarold Bornstein, Trump’s former doctor, informed Trump that he had already made public his 2016 campaign plans.
“If elected, Mr. Trump, I can state unequivocally, will be the healthiest individual ever elected to the presidency,” the letter said.
The “medical documents” plural that Judge Cannon cited as part of the justification for imposing a special counsel appears to be the letter the Trump campaign made public in 2016 claiming Trump was in excellent health (h/t @emptywheel) https://t.co/jomHwuAzku pic.twitter.com/C8IoHsmW23
— Charlie Savage (@charlie_savage) October 5, 2022
The “correspondence related to taxes and accounting information” that Cannon cited as a reason to order a special master review also appears to be a one-page letter, an IRS form regarding a deadline extension and an accounting firm retention letter, The New York Times‘ Charlie Savage reported.
There’s a second medical-related document but apparently not one about Trump personally, re individual interest analysis. pic.twitter.com/nDgtM1kovo
— Charlie Savage (@charlie_savage) October 5, 2022
Cannon appears to have “overstated the quantity of ‘personal records’ seized by the FBI that would justify a special master,” wroteAsha Rangappa, a former FBI agent special agent and CNNNational security analyst.
“The more we learn, even by accident, the worse things look for Judge Aileen Cannon,” wroteLaurence Tribe, Harvard Law Professor
The letter further raised suspicions over “how far Cannon went to appease” the president who appointed her, reported The Daily Beast’s Jose Pagliery, noting that Trump’s lawyers have “gone judge-shopping for her in the past” and seemed to do it again to avoid the judge that authorized the Mar-a-Lago search warrant by marking the case as unrelated to other pending litigation and diverting the case to another judge who ended up being a Trump appointee.
“I just don’t think she ever had jurisdiction,” Carl Tobias, a law professor at the University of Richmond, told The Daily Beast. “She could have kicked this back to the magistrate. To the extent this case had any validity, it belonged there — rather than have this. They forum-shopped for her. It raises all kinds of issues.”
Peter Shane, a legal scholar at New York University’s law school, added that Cannon is giving Trump the “delay he asked for.”
“She has obvious sympathy for Trump’s contention that, as a former president, he deserves super-consideration,” he told the outlet.
Cannon tried to block the DOJ’s investigation at Trump’s behest and agreed to his request to appoint a special master, picking longtime federal Judge Raymond Dearie from a list proposed by Trump’s lawyers. When Dearie was appointed pressed Trump’s lawyers to provide evidence of Trump’s dubious claim that he “declassified” the documents he took home, Cannon overruled his order.
“This is how a judge would behave… if her motivation was simply to be helpful to Trump,” Shane told The Daily Beast.
The DOJ successfully appealed before the 11th Circuit Court to obtain permission to review about 100 documents marked classifiedThese were taken from Mar-a-Lago. On Wednesday, the court again sided with DOJ agreeing to expedite an appeal that could shut down the entire “special master” process. Some legal experts even wonder if Dearie, who has been a federal Judge for 38 years, will comply with Cannon’s orders. Cannon was appointed to the federal bench in 2020.
“She seems to be cooperating quite well with the former president,” Tobias told The Daily Beast. Dearie “is a person who spent 38 years building his enormous reputation. If I were a judge for 38 years… I wouldn’t want to be ordered around by someone who’s a lackey to Trump.”
