Best Brow Gels for Fuller, Thicker and More Defined Brows

Us Weekly is an affiliate partner, so we may get compensation for certain links to products and/or services.

Brow trends have steadily changed over the decades, and right now, the look that’s front and center is focused on a more natural vibe. A great brow gel can help you achieve this look. Instead of creating an artificial shape with a brow pencil, a brow gel can give your hairs a tint and shape them into an arch that looks like you’re not wearing any makeup at all!

What are the Different Types of Brow gels I Can Purchase?

To start, brow gels can be divided into two types: tinted and clear. If you don’t want any added color and just want to use a gel to tape and keep your brows in place, clear is the way to go. Tinted should be your choice if you’re looking to add color to brow hairs that are darker or less visible.

There are a few more factors you should consider. Some brow gels have just the tint and the hold. Others have additional elements that can make your eyebrows look thicker or fuller. You also have a variety of pigment levels to choose. Do you need a brow gel with a lighter hue or a darker one that’s more opaque? There are brow gels that will make your hair naturally thicker or longer. These options are up to you, but we have compiled the best brow gels for all your needs. Continue reading to find your perfect match.

11 Amazing Brow Gels that Shape, Fill, and Volumize Brow hairs

Anastasia Beverly Hills Tinted Brow Cream

This brow gel is known for its clear version, which is why it is so popular. The brand also offers tinted versions of their product! The gel is long-lasting and has light-reflecting pearls that enhance the brow hairs for a natural look.

Pros

• Strong hold
• Light tint
• Buildable color
• Amazing shade range

Cons

• Very affordable
• Not as much volumeting power

Available at: Amazon.com, Sephora. Ulta. Nordstrom

WUNDER2 Wunderbrow Waterproof Eyebrow Gel

This gel is the best multi-tasking brow gel. You actually get three different brushes included in the set — a spoolie, a flat angle brush and a finer brush to help you fill, define and brush out your brows to perfection. The gel is also waterproof so you won’t have to worry about it budging at all!

Pros

• Multiple brushes
• Waterproof formula
• Massive bestseller
• It’s great for all types and types of eyebrows

Cons

• There are not as many colors available
• For some, may be too heavy

Available at

NYX Thick it Stick It! Thickening Brow Gel Mascara

This gel helps your brows stay in line and enhances them. It also contains tiny plant-origin fibers that make your brows appear thicker than they really are. You can add layers to achieve the desired result. Customers report that their brows remain in place all day.

Pros

• Amazing shade range
• Volume-building formula
• Super affordable

Cons

• Some shoppers don’t love the applicator wand

Available at: Amazon, Ulta, Target, Walmart

Benefit Cosmetics GimmeBrow+ Tinted Volumizing Eyebrow Gel

This gel also contains microfibers which help build volume and fill in your eyebrows to give you a fuller look. The result is natural looking, and the only thing that makes this product different is the applicator. It’s a small spoolie which makes it easy to give your brows a precise shape!

Pros

• Great shade range available
• Applicator that is precise
• A light, but pigmented color

Cons

• More expensive
• Some people may find the hue too light.

Available at: Sephora. Ulta. Amazon. Target. Nordstrom

Essence Make me Brow Eyebrow Gel Mascara

You likely won’t get a better bang for your buck than this brow gel. The tube is only $4 and has the same fiber-filling capabilities as its more expensive counterparts. You’ll get the volume and shape definition you need with this seriously affordable product.

Pros

• Super low price
• Buildable color
• Volumizing

Cons

• There are not as many shades options
• Some people may find it too light of a color

Available at: Amazon. Ulta. Target

Grande Cosmetics GrandeBROW-FILL Volumizing Brow Gel

You’ve probably seen this brand’s lash serum before, and you can expect similar strengthening benefits from their brow gel! The gel not only gives you a color tint and hold, but it also contains peptides that can help your natural brows look more healthy over time.

Pros

• Brow conditioning formula
• Volume-enhancing

Cons

• Fewer shades available
• It may not be the best for very sparse eyebrows.

Available at: Amazon and Ulta

IT Cosmetics Brow Powerfiller Volumizing Tinted Fibre Eyebrow Gel

This brow gel is the best for those with slender brows. This unique brush design allows you to shape and fill your brows. You can also tint your existing brows for a complete look. The formula is also waterproof so your brows won’t start looking off-kilter after a couple of hours!

Pros

• Unique brush design
• More opaque color
• Perfect for sparsely brows

Cons

• Some shoppers feel that application can be confusing
• Shades are universal but not always the best match.

Available at: Ulta. Sephora. Nordstrom

bareMinerals Strength & Length Serum Infused Brow Gel

This brow gel works in two ways — it instantly boosts the volume of your brows with its formula and also helps your natural brows look fuller over time! The gel acts as a serum that’s infused with plant extracts to help promote natural brow growth — even before applying this gel.

Pros

• Natural brow growth
• Brush applicator with easy-to-use controls

Cons

• A little more expensive
• Fewer shades available

Available at: Ulta. Nordstrom. Amazon

Urban Decay Inked Brow Cream

This brow gel’s applicator is unique because it only comes with an angled brush as opposed to a spoolie. This is ideal if you want a sharper and more defined brow, plus the formula lasts up to 60 hours — which attests to its “Inked” namesake!

Pros

• Super long-lasting
• Great color payoff
• Nice shade range available

Cons

• More expensive
• Applicator love is not for everyone

Available at: Ulta. Amazon. Nordstrom

Too Faced Brow Gel Brush on Wig

If you want a more natural look, this lighter brow gel will work well. It doesn’t have the same volume-building fibers as some of the other products we’ve mentioned, but the color is buildable. The tip of the brush can also be used to fill in areas that are less dense.

Pros

• Lighter, but still buildable color
• Fill in with a spoolie angle
• It is great for controlling fluffy brows

Cons

• No volumizing microfibers
• A little more expensive
• There are not as many colors available

Available at: Ulta. Target. Nordstrom. Sephora

e.l.f. Wow Brow Gel

This is another fantastic formula if you don’t want to spend a ton of money on a brow gel! There are clay particles that act as hair fibers to give you a fuller look, and it’s buildable to get the exact brow you want. Shoppers say their results are incredibly natural-looking and note you truly can’t beat the price!

Pros

• Super affordable
• Volumizing
• For precise application, use a small brush

Cons

• Fewer shades available
• Some people say the pigment is too pale for their tastes.

Available at: Ulta Target, Amazon

Still haven’t found what you’re looking for? These related product articles are available below:

Take a look at our other picks and deals Here!