‘Asset Managers Are Prioritizing ESG Goals Over Profit,’ Rep. Fallon Says  

A Republican congressman on Tuesday slammed using environmental, social, and governance investing and mentioned that “asset managers are prioritizing ESG targets over revenue and risking Individuals’ hard-earned cash.”

“Tens of millions of Individuals throughout the nation belief their investments will probably be used to make a revenue and hopefully one which they will stay on comfortably in retirement as a result of what we’re actually after right here, what we’re all investing in the long run, is monetary safety,” Rep. Pat Fallon, R-Texas, mentioned at a listening to. “However today it’s not loopy for a lot of Individuals to marvel: will I even be capable to afford retirement?”

“This administration has pushed inflation by the roof, it’s at a 40-year excessive, and pushed the financial system to the brink of a serious recession, which all of us pray received’t occur, but it surely very properly might within the subsequent 12 months,” Fallon, chairman of the Financial Development, Vitality Coverage, and Regulatory Affairs committee, mentioned. “Now, because of Democrats’ ESG push, asset managers are prioritizing ESG targets over revenue and risking Individuals’ hard-earned cash.”

ESG, which stands for environmental, social, and governance, is a enterprise framework that elevates environmental and social causes over revenue and shareholder worth creation and has been popularized by some companies and monetary traders.

Home Oversight and Accountability subcommittees on Financial Development, Vitality Coverage, and Regulatory Affairs and Well being Care and Monetary Companies held a listening to Tuesday titled ESG Part II: The Cascading Impacts of ESG Compliance.

The total committee previously held a listening to in Might titled ESG Half I: An Examination of Environmental, Social, and Governance Practices with attorneys common.

“With ESG investing, companies are actually tasked with accounting not just for their very own carbon footprints, however perhaps the footprint of their contractors and suppliers, the race and gender of their company boards as a substitute of the benefit and efficiency of those self same company board members,” Fallon mentioned.

“I’m for the liberty to take a position your individual cash into the causes, you the consumer, truly believes in. However that’s not what’s occurring right here. Managers are investing your cash in causes they imagine in and we’re seeing actual penalties for Individuals’ retirements,” Rep. Lisa McClain, R-Mich., mentioned on the listening to. “Individuals’ retirement belongings have been down almost 15% final 12 months. Fifteen p.c.”

“This consists of state pension funds. State pension funds helps academics, librarians, firefighters, and different public sector staff,” McClain, chairwoman of the Well being Care and Monetary Companies subcommittee, mentioned.

McClain additionally mentioned, “Some states, equivalent to Texas and Kansas, are literally getting in entrance of this by advancing legal guidelines that limit investments that take into account non-financial components, keep in mind they’re within the monetary sector, they need to be specializing in monetary components, like ESG for state pension funds.”

Mandy Gunasekara, director of the Impartial Girls’s Discussion board Heart for Vitality & Conservation, Jason Isaac, director of of Life:Powered on the Texas Public Coverage Basis, and Stephen Moore, distinguished fellow in economics at The Heritage Basis, testified on Tuesday. Shivaram Rajgopal, Roy Bernard Kester and T.W. Byrnes professor of Accounting and Auditing at Columbia Enterprise College, was the Democrats’ witness.

“The ‘E’ requirements end in greater price power, unreliable electrical energy grids, and stand to undermine environmental progress,” Gunasekara mentioned. “The ‘E’ requirements additionally enrich high-end asset managers at BlackRock, State Avenue, and Vanguard on the expense of retirees and pensioners.”

“‘S’ requirements drive firms to have interaction in controversial political points, equivalent to campaigns to defund the police or selling ‘gender transitions’ in kids, cultivating division within the office and {the marketplace},” Gunasekara, who can also be a visiting fellow in The Heritage Basis’s Heart for Vitality, Local weather, and Setting, mentioned. “G’ requirements give the looks of range whereas proscribing freedom of thought and competing viewpoints within the workforce.” (The Day by day Sign is the information outlet of The Heritage Basis.)

“Now, ESG requirements are purposefully advanced and convoluted within the hopes that the on a regular basis man and girl is not going to catch on,” Gunasekara mentioned.

Jessica Anderson, government director of Heritage Motion for America, the grassroots arm of The Heritage Basis, weighed in on Tuesday’s listening to. 

“At present’s listening to is one other essential step in investigating and exposing the true price of progressive ESG insurance policies,” Anderson advised The Day by day Sign in an emailed assertion. “The coercion brought on by dangerous ESG compliance distorts enterprise danger assessments and upends the liberty of personal market choices.”

“Lawmakers at each the state and federal degree ought to proceed evaluating the specter of ESG and its affect on American industries,” Anderson mentioned.


Have an opinion about this text? To pontificate, please e-mail letters@DailySignal.com and we’ll take into account publishing your edited remarks in our common “We Hear You” characteristic. Keep in mind to incorporate the url or headline of the article plus your title and city and/or state.